He has a son who is now living with an uncle because a oneparent family, especially if the parent is the father, is deemed unsuitable. Usa, 2017, 82 minutes, in yiddish with english subtitles, rated pg, directed by joshua z weinstein. Set within the new york hasidic community in borough park, brooklyn, menashe follows a kind but hapless grocery store clerk named menashe trying to maintain custody of his son rieven after his wife, lea, passes away. It premiered at the sundance film festival in january 2017, where it was acquired by a24 for u. Apr 20, 2017 within brooklyns ultraorthodox jewish community, a widower battles for custody of his son. The movie is not heartwarming as the intro says, but totally realistic, and distressing at times. The 67th berlin international film festival announced 43 additions to its 2017 roster today, including alex ross perrys golden exits, joshua z. Weinsteins film achieves this initially by putting a soulful gaze on a world we rarely see in american film, the hasidic community of new. Aug 17, 2017 menashe menashe lustig is a member of an ultraorthodox jewish community in new york. Weinstein world a young widower struggles to appease orthodox tradition and raise his son without a mother in this touching and funny observational drama, shot in yiddish in a camerashy hassidic neighbourhood in brooklyn.
A tender drama performed entirely in yiddish, the film intimatel. The edinburgh international film festival limited is a subsidiary of the centre for the moving image. A less daring film maker would have made an ideal parent of menashe, but the portly shop assistant, though endlessly kind, is forever at home to everyday disasters. Menashe, played by himself has been widowed a year earlier. English by joshua z weinstein with menashe lustig, ruben niborski. Deep in the heart of new yorks ultraorthodox hasidic jewish community, menashe a kind, hapless grocery store clerkstruggles to make ends meet and responsibly parent his young son, rieven. A film based on the real life story of its lead, a nonactor from brooklyn, as he fights to keep his son after his wifes death has connected with festival audiences and critics alike as a tiny film about a hapless hasidic jew, starring nonactors speaking almost entirely in yiddish, hopes for menashes reception were modest, to say the. And while the arcane world that it recreates is one that will be unfamiliar to most viewers, the sentiments within it are highly.
Weinstein, the director, shot the film in yiddish and often in secret in hasidic. I had high hopes for menashe, but left the film disappointed. The strike price, or the production price as it is sometimes referred, is the amount that the completion guarantor believes will be needed in order to complete and deliver the film. Since they live in a traditionbound culture that requires a mother present in.
A24 presents menashe, from director joshua z weinstein. Copresented by the tucson international jewish film fest ival. The story does not seem to have reached a satisfying conclusion and that. With menashe lustig, josh alpert, abraham bresky, jorge cea.
Shot in secret entirely within the hasidic community depicted in the film, and one of the only movies to be performed in yiddish in nearly 70 years, menashe is a warm, lifeaffirming look at the universal bonds between father and son that also sheds unusual light on a notoriously private community. An excellent film that resisted facile sentimentality and revealed character depth. Menashe usa, israel 2017 yiddish, english, 81 min subtitle. Shot in secret entirely within the hasidic community depicted in the film, and one of the only movies to be performed in yiddish in nearly 70 years, menashe is a warm, life affirming look at the universal bonds between father and son that also sheds unusual light on. How did a sundance filmmaker shoot a scripted movie in the. Based largely on the real life of its hasidic star menashe lustig, the film is a strikingly authentic and deeply moving portrait of family, love, connection, and community. The 2010 romeo and juliet in yiddish was an independent production which employed formerly ultraorthodox nonprofessional actors.
Menashe is a moving drama of hasidic life joshua weinsteins debut fiction film is a powerful, if smallscoped, depiction of a father and son living in a closed society. The plot is a touch obvious, but menashe still plays like a more culturally specific kramer vs. The most emotionally honest film youll see this year. Menashe 2017 new zealand international film festival. The centre for the moving image is a company limited by guarantee with charitable status. Dec 10, 2017 t his terrifically authentic look at life inside new yorks yiddishspeaking hasidic community is a bittersweet treat a vibrantly engaging portrait of downtoearth lives that is. Menashe 2017 cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more. Weinstein brings a palpable authenticity attributable in part to a cast made up of local nonactors to this universally resonant story, rendering it unique and specific in a meticulously detailed setting. Several months ago, i started seeing promos for menashe, which premiered at the sundance film festival in january 2017. Menashe 2017 deep in the heart of new yorks notoriously secretive hasidic jewish community, menashe, a goodhearted but somewhat hapless grocery store clerk, struggles against tradition to keep custody of his only son after his wife passes away.
If the synopsis were phrased, based on the real life story of a figure within a secret society, we would likely be prepared for either a spy movie or yet another undercover look at a cult. Within brooklyns ultraorthodox jewish community, a widower battles for custody of his son. Kramer, setting up a testy, fascinating dynamic between micromanaging rabbis and a naturally warm. Weinsteins brooklynbased yiddish drama is an authentic, tightly written, compelling story for anyone jonesing to hear more than a bisl little bit of the. In 2008, the student film my fathers house, about two holocaust survivors during the 1948 arabisraeli war, was made in israel. Something like woody allen meets neorealism in borough park, brooklyn, menashe follows its titular hapless protagonist through a host of existential, spiritual, and familial crises. Menashe lustig and yoel falkowitz in menashe 2017 joshua z weinstein and. Find out where menashe 2017 is streaming, if menashe 2017 is on netflix, and get news and updates, on decider. By dramatizing the relationship between parents and children, the film explores one of. A tender drama performed entirely in yiddish, the film intimately explores the nature of faith and the price of parenthood.
Menashe, which premiered within a couple days interval at the 2017 sundance and berlin international film festivals to public and critical acclaim, is the first yiddishlanguage feature film starring native yiddish speakers to be produced in more than sixty years with the notable exception of a gesheftthe deal, which remains the sole. Based largely on the real life of its hasidic star menashe lustig, the film is a strikingly authentic and deeply moving portrait of family, love, connection and community. Starring nebbishes and noodges, yiddish cinema makes a. Making an independent film onlocation in brooklyns hasidic community, and almost completely in yiddish, is not the most obvious way to lure people into a theater.
Jul 27, 2017 another scene, when menashe is on a date arranged by a matchmaker, generates both winces and laughs. Deep in the heart of new yorks notoriously secretive hasidic jewish community, menashe, a goodhearted but somewhat hapless grocery store clerk, struggles against tradition to keep custody of his. Film star on raising his son as a hasidic jew duration. Jul 27, 2017 menashe, the film and the character, share a sweet spirit. T his terrifically authentic look at life inside new yorks yiddishspeaking hasidic community is a bittersweet treat a vibrantly engaging portrait of downtoearth lives that is. Menashe is a moving drama of hasidic life the atlantic. However, it is impossible to evaluate good or bad before watch menashe 2017 full movie.
Menashe s son is adorable, sensitive, and his facial expressions reveal he knows more than he can or is willing to. Weinsteins first narrative feature, does something similar, with a twist. A less daring filmmaker would have made an ideal parent of menashe, but the portly shop assistant, though endlessly kind, is forever at home to everyday disasters. In the wake of his wifes recent death, menashe must care for his tenyearold sondespite the fact that he knows. Shot in secret entirely within the hasidic community depicted in the film, and one of the only movies to be performed in yiddish in nearly 70 years, menashe is a warm, life affirming look at the universal bonds between father and son that also sheds unusual light on a notoriously private community. Menashe has affinities with yiddish cinema of the 1930s in other ways. Menashe grants the viewer access into to a hasidic community in new york through the life of a struggling widower. Menashes son is adorable, sensitive, and his facial expressions reveal he knows more than he can or is willing to. In 2014 he had just completed a series of difficult shoots involving subjects such as poor. Berlin film festival adds golden exits and menashe to.
Eventually, through a film making friend, he found his man. In the wake of his wifes recent death, menashe must care for his tenyearold sondespite the fact that he knows bupkis about parentingat the. He works at a grocery store where his hispanic coworkers have dubbed the bearish fellow gordito. And while the arcane world that it recreates is one that will be unfamiliar to most viewers, the sentiments within it. Aug 02, 2017 menashe is a moving drama of hasidic life joshua weinsteins debut fiction film is a powerful, if smallscoped, depiction of a father and son living in a closed society. Menashe premiered at the sundance film festival where it was acquired by a24, the indie distributors first foreignlanguage buy. Jan 18, 2017 the 67th berlin international film festival announced 43 additions to its 2017 roster today, including alex ross perrys golden exits, joshua z. Like all great films that nudge the world toward being a slightly more compassionate place, the creation of menashe is an act of empathy. National catholic register israeli filmmaker rama burshteins debut film fill the void 2012 and her followup the wedding plan 2016 take the viewer into the hidden world of hasidic jewish communities in israel. Winner of the rooftop films brigade festival publicity grant. Starring menashe lustig, yoel falkowitz, ruben niborski, meyer schwartz, yoel weisshaus. Always remember dont trust the opinion of menashe 2017 on the internet because the authors paid to write a comment. Jul 28, 2017 like all great films that nudge the world toward being a slightly more compassionate place, the creation of menashe is an act of empathy. As the film comes to an uncertain conclusion, weinstein does allow the rabbi one touching moment of sympathy towards our.
The 2014 felix and meira and 2017 menashe depicted scenes from the life of hasidim. Menashe, the film and the character, share a sweet spirit. In the event production of the film is abandoned, the completion guarantor will fully repay all sums invested in the film by the bank or financiers. Alex lipschultz, musa syeed menashe 2017 full movie. Weinstein s film achieves this initially by putting a soulful gaze on a world we rarely see in american film, the hasidic community of new york city, using nonactors who. Menashe menashe lustig is a scruffy and slightly ramshackle grocer in new yorks hasidic jewish community. The rabbi believes that children should not be raised without a mother and wont allow menashes young son rieven to live with him. Weinstein graduates to narrative features with this intimate account of an ultraorthodox jewish widower at risk of losing his son due to strict religious tradition. Menashe is a gorgeous ode to everyones inner screwup.
Stream now some commentators say that menashe 2017 is a good movie, although some of them say that menashe 2017 is a bad movie. Struggling to rebuild his life following the death of his wife, he longs to be reunited with his son rieven ruben niborski, whos been temporarily placed in the care of his uptight brotherinlaw yoel weisshaus until menashe remarries, in line with orthodox tradition. Menashe lustig and ruben nyborg appear in menashe by joshua weinstein. Weinsteins brooklynbased yiddish drama is an authentic, tightly written, compelling story for anyone jonesing to hear more than a bisl little bit of the mamaloshen mother tongue. An excellent film that resisted facile sentimentality and revealed character depth with a well wrought unfolding of the plot. There have been only a few movies over the years which successfully depict the hasidic world with nuance and depth and have gotten critical acclaim ushpizin, fill the void and the wedding plan. Eventually, through a filmmaking friend, he found his man. Menashe, a complex and lovable schlemiel, is a young widower fighting to retain custody of his son deep in the heart of new yorks ultraorthodox hasidic jewish community. Another scene, when menashe is on a date arranged by a matchmaker, generates both winces and laughs.
669 795 287 104 142 1330 1410 624 608 453 589 25 100 1511 1133 206 534 1298 1298 1305 722 795 1374 889 72 940 213 1257 489 482 242 224 331 1009 5 822 493 1079 1357 1335 1230 1023